Understanding Exceptional Hardship: A Guide to Avoiding Driving Disqualifications

Exceptional Hardship is the only legal mechanism available to avoid a driving disqualification when you accumulate 12 or more penalty points. Under the Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988 (Section 35), hitting 12 points triggers an automatic minimum 6-month ban. This is known as “Totting Up.”

However, the Court has the discretion not to disqualify you, or to reduce the ban, if you can prove that disqualification would cause suffering beyond what is reasonably expected. This is the legal test of “Exceptional Hardship.”

The Legal Threshold: Hardship vs. Inconvenience

The law accepts that losing your licence is supposed to be a punishment. Therefore, the Court expects you to suffer some degree of hardship. To avoid a ban, your hardship must be Exceptional.

Common Myths vs. Legal Reality

The “Innocent Third Party” Rule (Cornwall v Coke)

The strongest arguments focus on the impact on others. Case law (Cornwall v Coke 1976) established that while the driver deserves punishment, innocent parties (children, employees, elderly relatives) do not. If your ban causes suffering to them, the Court is more likely to show leniency.

 

5 Valid Grounds for Exceptional Hardship

While every case is unique, the following 5 grounds are most commonly accepted by Magistrates when supported by evidence.

1. Loss of Employment Leading to Homelessness

You must demonstrate a “Chain of Events” that leads to disaster:

• Step 1: Disqualification leads to immediate dismissal (Employer Letter required).
• Step 2: Dismissal leads to inability to pay mortgage/rent (Financial Audit required).
• Step 3: Lack of funds leads to repossession or eviction.

2. Business Insolvency (Impact on Employees)

If you are a business owner, the Court will be concerned if your disqualification would force the business to close. The hardship here falls on your employees, who would lose their jobs through no fault of their own.

3. Care for Vulnerable Relatives

If you provide essential care for an elderly, disabled, or sick relative, you must pass the “Taxi Test”: Why can’t they take a taxi? Valid reasons include:

• They suffer from dementia and cannot travel with strangers.
• They have physical disabilities requiring specialist lifting/assistance.
• They are immunocompromised and cannot use public transport.

4. Impact on Children (Health & Education)

This applies if a ban would deprive a child of essential education or healthcare. It is particularly strong if the child has Special Educational Needs (SEN) or attends a specialist school with no transport links.

5. Specialised Public Service

If you work in a role that is vital to the community, such as an emergency utility engineer, NHS consultant, or vet, and your inability to attend emergencies would harm the public.

The Court Hearing: Preparing for “The Grill”

Exceptional Hardship is not a paperwork exercise. You must give evidence under oath. The Prosecutor or Legal Advisor will cross-examine you to test your honesty.

3 Tough Questions to Prepare For

Your motoring solicitor will prepare you for these common lines of questioning:

1. The Lifestyle Question: “You say you can’t afford taxis, yet your bank statements show you spend £200 a month on socialising/cigarettes/Sky TV. Why can’t you cut that spending to pay for travel?”
2. The Partner Question: “Why can’t your partner/spouse drive you? Are they insured on the vehicle?”
3. The Relocation Question: “If your job is so important, why can’t you move closer to your workplace or stay in a B&B during the week?”

Evidence Checklist: The “Court Bundle”

Your verbal testimony is rarely enough. You need a “Court Bundle” of physical documents to prove your claims on the balance of probabilities.

Financial Evidence

• Mortgage/Rent Statements: Showing your monthly liability.
• Loan/Credit Card Agreements: Proving debts and lack of savings.
• Statement of Means: A detailed breakdown of Income vs. Expenditure.

Medical & Employment Evidence

• Employer Letter: Explicitly stating: “We have explored other roles, but [Name] will be dismissed if they lose their licence.”
• GP/Consultant Letters: Confirming the diagnosis of any relative you care for.
• Business Accounts: If self-employed, showing the reliance of the company on your mobility.

Potential Outcomes of the Hearing

If the Magistrates accept your argument, there are three potential outcomes:

1. Found Exceptional (No Ban): You are not disqualified. The 12+ penalty points remain on your licence for 3 years, but they do not trigger a ban. You effectively drive on a “final warning.”
2. Short Period Disqualification: The Court finds hardship, but decides it is not sufficient to avoid a ban entirely. They may disqualify you for a short period (e.g., 14-28 days) rather than the full 6 months.
3. Argument Rejected (6 Month Ban): The Court finds your hardship is merely “inconvenience.” You are disqualified for the mandatory minimum of 6 months.

• About
• Latest Posts

Neil Davies

Follow me here at LinkedIn

I am a criminal lawyer with over 25 years of experience and specialising in the defence of Road Traffic (driving) prosecutions and the founder and Senior Partner of Caddick Davies Solicitors.

Latest posts by Neil Davies (see all)

• Common Myths: Speeding & Speed Cameras - October 1, 2025
• Can Needing To Go To The Toilet Provide A Defence To A Motoring Offence - June 19, 2025
• Can I Drive With MOT Advisories? The Legal Position Explained - June 19, 2025