Embarrassing insurance case is no laughing matter

Ignorance of the law is no excuse but a simple mistake can still lead to a serious motoring offence for even the most sensible driver, as was illustrated in a rather embarrassing case for Scotland’s Transport Minister recently.

Humza Yousaf was caught driving a friend’s car without the proper insurance, highlighting this complex issue many motorists are still unaware of and following the incident the minister blamed the ‘genuine mistake’ on a misunderstanding following his recent break-up from his wife.

The SNP politician was said to have been driving a friend’s car when he was pulled over by police who were carrying out routine checks, which later showed that Mr Yousaf was only insured to drive his own vehicle.

The pair, who were on their way to catch a ferry from Ullapool to a St Andrew’s Day dinner in Stornoway, are thought to have been sharing the driving on the journey. Mr Yousaf said he later discovered that, following the breakup of his marriage and transfer of ownership of the couple’s car, he did not complete the process of taking over as the main policy holder.

Certificate of motor insurance and policy schedule with car key

Certificate of motor insurance and policy schedule with car key

Mr Yousaf admitted driving without insurance and said he would plead guilty at the earliest opportunity. He said he thought he had comprehensive car insurance that allowed him to driver other vehicles, but he discovered that after the split from his wife and transfer of ownership of the couple’s car, he was no longer the main policy holder and was subsequently no longer insured to drive other vehicles.

“I believed I was in possession of fully comprehensive insurance,” said Mr Yousaf. “Not just for my own car, and as such that I was insured to drive vehicles other than my own. If I had had even the slightest doubt about my insurance I would not have driven the car. However I remained insured to drive my own car at all times throughout.”

If nothing else this case acts as a lesson for motorists in how easy it is to break the law, even if they think they are doing nothing wrong; something that Senior Partner at Caddick Davies, Neil Davies, is keen to emphasise.

“This case shows just how easy it is for even the most careful of motorists to fall foul of the law on motoring insurance,” he explains. “If you drive a vehicle without insurance you are guilty of an offence even if you did so because of an honest mistake and this will result in, either a fixed penalty notice (£300 and 6 penalty points), or court proceedings with a maximum fine of £5,000 and between 6 and 9 penalty points.

“In some cases however, where a person has driven without insurance by reason of a genuine and honest mistake and this has been caused by something beyond their control, the magistrates’ court may be asked to exercise their discretion not to endorse any penalty points (and often not to impose any fine) on the grounds of ‘special reasons’.

“Examples of this can include cases where a motorist’s insurance policy has been cancelled without their knowledge or where a motorist has relied on a family member who has informed them that they are insured to drive the vehicle.

“The important lesson in this case is perhaps to check that you are covered to drive any vehicle that you are driving before doing so, especially if you are a Transport Minister!”

Latest From Us


Behind the Headlines: New speeding guidelines explained

Drivers found guilty of the most serious speeding offences could face harsher penalties under new sentencing guidelines, but some confusion still surrounds the new law change. Stricter punishment for drivers committing the...

Call us for a free consultation 03334 432 366 or connect with us info@caddickdavies.co.uk

Providing national coverage & representation for all major cities across England & Wales including:

  • London
  • Birmingham
  • Cardiff
  • Carlisle
  • Liverpool
  • Leeds
  • Manchester
  • Newcastle
  • Sheffield

Request a Callback?


We are open for business & have measures in place to keep our team safe. Please stay at home and follow government guidance.